Why Yankees traded Jordan Montgomery to Cardinals for Harrison Bader

A day after trading for Frankie Montas to bolster their rotation, the Yankees subtracted one of their most consistent starters just before the trade deadline.

The Yankees sent lefty Jordan Montgomery to the Cardinals on Tuesday in exchange for outfielder Harrison Bader and a player to be named later or cash considerations.

Bader is currently on the injured list with plantar fasciitis and in a walking boot. That could delay his Yankees debut until September, general manager Brian Cashman said. When Bader is available, the Yankees will get a strong defensive center fielder and speed threat who is also under contract through next season.

But it came at the cost of Montgomery, the homegrown pitcher who was visibly emotional and still in shock about an hour after the trade went down.

“I didn’t acquire Montas so I could move Monty,” Cashman said after the deadline had passed. “Me and my staff entered the trade acquisition market of exports and imports trying to figure out the overall ecosystem of that roster and what fits best with a plan for October and how could we best be flying high at the best of our abilities when it counts the most in October and what gives us the most amount of quality choices? That’s what went into every single decision we made.

Jordan Montgomery
Jordan Montgomery
Corey Sipkin

“So we’re excited about what Bader can bring down the line for us. We have to wait on it, we get that. But it came at the expense of a quality choice we already had.”

The trade capped off a busy few days for Cashman — who filled holes in left field (Andrew Benintendi), the rotation (Montas) and the bullpen (Scott Effross and Lou Trivino) while also trading Joey Gallo to the Dodgers.

“The biggest part of it is just kind of that sadness of seeing a guy [leave] that you love and that you’ve been through a lot with and that’s done a lot for this team and organization,” manager Aaron Boone said after an 8-6 loss to the Mariners. “Coming out of nowhere today where that happens, it’s hard delivering that news and saying goodbye.”

Even after acquiring Montas from the Athletics on Monday, the Yankees continued to explore adding another starting pitcher before the deadline, Cashman said. The Post’s Joel Sherman and Jon Heyman reports that the Yankees were in on Marlin’s right-hander Pablo Lopez, though a deal never came to fruition.

Instead, the Yankees will move forward with a rotation of Gerrit Cole, Montas, Jameson Taillon, Nestor Cortes and Domingo German before hoping that a healthy Luis Severino joins them in mid-September when he is eligible to come off the 60-day IL. They also have another option in Clarke Schmidt at Triple-A, though they gutted much of their starting depth beyond that in trades over the last few days.

“I’m confident [in the rotation],” Cashman said. “My job is always to worry, but I believe in the guys we have.”

Harrison Bader
Harrison Bader
Getty Images

Montgomery, who was drafted by the organization in 2014, appeared crushed to not be part of that rotation moving forward.

“This is my family. This is all I know,” said Montgomery, who had a 3.69 ERA through 21 starts this season. “I still don’t really think I ever performed the way I should have here. I’m a lot better player than I’ve ever shown to the fans. But I think I was consistent, and I gave the team a chance to win.”

The Yankees could face Montgomery this weekend in St. Louis, as he would be on turn to pitch against them.

But they’ll have to wait on Bader, whom Cashman called “one of the elite center field defenders in the game.” His presence will allow the Yankees to play Aaron Judge more consistently in right field. The 28-year-old Bader, a Bronxville native who won a Gold Glove in 2021, was batting .256/.303/.370 with 15 steals in 72 games this year.

The Yankees entered Tuesday with the best record in baseball, but that did not make Cashman stand pat.

“Ultimately our record through Aug. 2 won’t guarantee us anything in October,” Cashman said. “It’s the accumulation of talent, keeping it healthy and playing to maximum ability. Just because we played exceptional baseball thru Aug. 1 … doesn’t mean we get to kick back and assume it continues that way.”


Leave a Comment